Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, conse ctetur adip elit, pellentesque turpis.

Image Alt

Lesson Tutor : Schumann/Brahms Assignment

  /  Lesson Tutor : Schumann/Brahms Assignment

Schumann/Brahms Assignment
by Elaine Ernst Schneider


As a young man, Johannes Brahms was a close friend of Robert and Clara Schumann. They socialized publicly and Johannes was often in the Schumann home. When Robert Schumann died, Johannes continued his friendship with Clara. Clara Schumann, herself a renowned pianist, gave concerts that showcased her late husband’s work to support herself and her children. It is not known whether Johannes had always loved Clara or if the affection sprang from the relationship that grew after Robert’s death. History does tell us that Brahms professed his love for Clara though they never married.
For more detailed biographies of each of these classical composers, refer to:
Johannes Brahms, and Robert Schumann, by Betty Fry.

Assignment Choices:

1. Write a dialogue that might have taken place between Clara and Johannes after Robert’s death. Begin the conversation with Brahms confessing to Clara that he loves her. Use your imagination. Here are some questions to get you started thinking:
– What might Brahms say to Clara to first open up the subject of his love for her?
– Does Brahms propose marriage or is it he who never asks, rather than she who refuses?
– What might have been Clara’s reasons for not marrying Johannes Brahms? Was she still in love with Robert? Did Clara fear that if she married Brahms that it would be too awkward to continue concertizing with Robert’s pieces? Or was there some other reason she refused Brahms’ affection?

2. Write the lyrics for a song Brahms might have written for Clara. Keep in mind that words for songs during this time period usually rhymed.

3. If you play an instrument, create an original short piece that Brahms might have written for Clara. Consider the emotions of love and how they might be conveyed through the music. Would the tempo be slow and the tone sad because love is unrequited, or might the tempo be fast and furious to show the frustration of two souls that never connect?
As you begin these assignments, remember to keep in mind what was and was not “socially acceptable” in Johannes and Clara’s day. Also know that Brahms’ love for Clara was made somewhat public when he dedicated several songs to her. Clara Schumann died in 1889. Brahms attended her graveside funeral. It was a cold and damp day and Brahms caught a “chill.” He died just a few months later. Was it from the chill? Or was it from a lonely heart? You decide.

For more Articles by this Author, Click Here

For more Lesson Plans in the Subject: Music General, click Here

Subtraction Action

Multiplication Stations

Hooverville Problems

Who Ordered the Mango Mash?

Blender Blunders

Let’s Get Some Order in Here!

Decimal Dilemma

There’s a Pattern Here

An Ancient Chinese Puzzle

Addition Mission

Adding Money

What do You Like to Read?

World Religions

Leaders of the World

States and Capitals 3

States and Capitals 2

States and Capitals 1

State Abbreviations 3

State Abbreviations 2

State Abbreviations 1

Map of the United States

Landform Chart

Know Your States


The World Around Us

I Can Dream

Relate to the Leader

The Story of Christmas

On the Phone

Conflict Corner

Reading Comprehension

The Presidents of the Country

Know Thy Neighbor

Guess My Name

About Washington

Cracking Labor Day

Double Puzzle on Labor Day

Great Samaritans

People and Their Instruments

Work and You

Tiger Trivia

You Make My Heart Throb

Types of Invertebrates

Classification of Plants

They are Almost Dead


Divide and Conquer

Unlocking Multiplication

Madame Pomreeda’s Powers

Don’t Bug Me

Stir It Up

Witch’s Brew

Casting a Spell

Vampire Maze

Longing for Division

The Enchanted Forest

Keys to the Door

Simple Fractions

Easter Math Problems

Yes or No

Do Your Duties

Search for Your Clothes

Caramel Carnations

Tombstone Toss-up

The Vampire’s Cats

Peanut Butter n’ Jelly Picnic

Ghostly Parts of Speech

Get a Clue

Caught in the Web

Punctuation Practice

The Haunted Castle

I Have a Dream

Proofread the Dream

Summer Cool


Erstwhile Letters

Exploring Venus

Integers Addition

Locating the Eiffel Tower

Locating the Taj Mahal

Natural Calamity: Earthquakes

Rhyming Words

Three Dimensions

Clear the Confusion

It Could Always Be Worse

Count to Ten

Anansi and the Visitor

Three Strong Women

Stone Soup

Frog’s Fiesta

Two of Everything

Country Mouse, City Mouse

The Magic Tortilla

Tante Odette

Woolly and the Cave Kids: True or False

Woolly and the Cave Kids: What a Week!

Woolly and the Cave Kids: Word Meanings

Woolly and the Cave Kids: Word Usage

Know Your Nouns – IV

Know Your Nouns – III

The Cave Kids: Riddle Time

The Cave Kids: Picture That

The Cave Kids: Word Meanings

The Cave Kids: Word Usage

Telescope Decoder

More Than One

Present and Past

Synonyms Match

Antonyms at the Art Gallery

Beasley and Homophones

Maestro’s Mix-up

Bothoven’s Message

Perfect Tense

It’s Easy!

What’s the Adjective?

Fun with Homophones

Summer Holidays are Fun!

Do the Opposite!

Jimble Jumble

Favorite Festival

Biosphere Mix-Up Fix-Up

Take a Hike

Who’s in the Ocean!

Mort’s Stomachache

Robot Buffet

Place Values

Pretty Smart, Mort

We Need More Power!

More Juice

Mega Power Surge

Power Up!

Will Somebody Get the Door?

It All Multiplies

Around The World

Multiply into 5!

Sweet Tooth

Know Thy Rugby

Do You Know Him? II

Do You Know Him?

Locate and Color

Continents and Oceans

America, America

States and Capitals

My Home Rules

Good Habits

Bad Habits

Easter Essay

Laugh Riot

Research Report 3 & 4

Essay Writing: My Summer Vacation

Book Report 3 & 4

A Special Memory

World’s Best Father!

Make Them Sound Good

Locked Out

Antonyms: Step-by-Step

Sound Alikes

Fast and Fearless: Reflections

Fast and Fearless: Similar or Opposite?

Fast and Fearless: Word Meanings

Fast and Fearless

Paint’s Vacation: Reflections

Paint’s Vacation: True or False

Paint’s Vacation: Word Meanings

Prefix Perfect

Meanings, Spellings, and Matching

Pilings Puzzler

Machu Picchu

Predicates, Please

Subject Surprises

Adverb Adventure

Caves of Cumae

Batty About Verbs

Noun Gems

Words of the Past

Temple of Plurals

Blasting Off With Verbs

Beautiful Fruits

Spelling Duel

Months of the Year

Order by Alphabet

Wheel of Words

All About Adjectives

Love Affection Adoration

Put the Words in Place

Reading for Mom

Planet Positions

Hot or Cold?

Life Cycle of a Plant

Arranged in Order

Earthly Features

Growing a Plant

Know What They Are!

Plant and Sun

Football Fun

Do You Carry The Ball?